Muhammad Mubashir Nazir			محمد مبشر نذیر
Home	Risk Management	Adventure & Tourism		Ethics & Religion
Install Urdu Font	Install Urdu Keyboard	Back to Safarnama		Post your comments

Comments from Readers قارئین کے تاثرات

Anonymous

Asalam u Alikum

Main apka safar namah arh rahi hoon ajkal.MashaAllah boht hi achi koshish hai apki...jis terha app ne sath sath aqeedah ko darust karne ki koshish ki hai aur jaise apni islamic info ko bayan kiya hai its really cool.Wahan maza ata hi tub hai jab app ko pehly see sari info maloom hoon.Like Uhad k maidan main wo manzar soch kar insan ki ankhein ansoo see bhar jati hain k Yahin 70 sahaba R.A shahhed huay.jaggah itni sakhat k khodi nahin jati.Garmi see bura haal.wasael itne kam k kuffan mayasar nahin.Hazart Hamza RA ki na'ash mubarak ka muslah kar diya gaya........Nabi SAW k dant mubarak shaheed hoo gay..........Kitni mushkalat deen k liye un logon ne uthien aur ajj hum ne deen ki kiya halat kar di

Har har qadam per koe na koe tareekhi baat wa basta hai......mere khayal main jane se pehly in sab batoon ka ilm hoo tou insan zaidayah kuch seekh sakta hai.but tragic sceen is of pakistanis there.

Mujhy Allah ne apna ghar dekhaya hai aur mujhy bohut Maza aya.Meri zindgi ka pehla safar tha aur wo b boht khoobsurat jegha ka.

mera apko mail karne ka maqsad yeh hai k tareeq e Madinah k rasty main jahan app ne monkey ka sign daikha wahan per aik basti hai usko bandroon ki basti kaha jata hai.wahan bander sadiyon see abad hain.aur boht cute harkatein karty hain.....loog unko daikhne jaty hain unk liye khana lay kar jaty hain.wo koe aik doo nahin bulk boht sainkroon bander hain wahan.......

yeh info mere abbu ne mujhy di hai kiun k unhoon ne us jagha ko daikha hua hai.mujhy boht shooq tha k main daikhoon.abbu ne wada b kiya tha k dikhaoon ga magar driver ne na jaty huay humari suni na madina see wapisi per.u know better k unk moods kaise hoty hain...

I request k app us place ka pata kar k ussy zaroor visit karin.

Madinah main aurtoon k sath hone wala salook daikh kar dil boht kharab hua.yahan see hum kiya kiya soch kar jaty hain aur wahan itne rush main zehni sakoon milna hi dushwar ho jata hai..........Apki wife ne bilkul sahi kaha.u know wahan sirf aik suf rayaz ul jannah ki di jati hai aurtoon ko.aur namaz k douraan hi wo apko utha k bahir bhaigna suru kar deti hain.halat kuch yoon hoo jati hain k niyat kahin bhandi,sajdah kahin aur aur salam kahin aur........

Jazak Allah for entertaining me through ur safar namah.....

Aik request agar ho sake tou mujhy duaon main yad kar lein jab wahan jain k Allah mujhy isteqamat fi deen ata kar day aur mujhy Allah us usk Rasool SAW ki sachi mouhabbat Naseeb hoo jaye.

Fi aman Allah

Dr. Henna Khan, UK

Many congrats Mubashir on this achievement. Thank you for keeping us informed. Do post it/link to the www.studying-islam.org forums as well so our members can benefit

Mr. Asim Vardaq, Karachi, Pakistan

Hi Mubashir,

Many thanks for your email through which you introduced me to your website. I just finished your safarnama and liked it immensely. I liked the personal touch you gave it by comparing various location with those in Pakistan. Your comments about the food of various countires were hilarious. It shows you deep interest in history and geography and sociology. I want to share with you a book by Chris Harman " The Prophet and the Proletariat". This is available at http://www.swp.org.uk/swp_archive_list.php?issue_id=236.

Here Harman has analysed the phenomenon of Islamism in Egypt, Algeria, Sudan and Iran from a class angle. Do have a look at it and and I would love to have your comments on it. Famous British reporter Robert Fisk has also written a book " The great war for civilization " about his experiences in the Middle east. Looking at your interest in this area, it is a must read. Lets hope you get chances to roam around more countries and then share those experiences also. Asim Vardaq

Thank you very much for your kind comments and providing links. I've copied the book of Chris Harman and will provide you my comments after reading it very soon. Can you please provide the link of Robert Fisk's book? I've a plan to visit more countries in near future Insha Allah and will write their safarnama as well. Please remember me in your prayers and continue providing your valuable feedback on my writings. Please also provide your detailed introduction and keep in touch in future. Mubashir

Mr. Muhammad Ali Zaidi, Lahore, Pakistan

Dear Brother: Don’t you think that Haq is a subjective concept and issue as you are presenting it according to your understanding but it would be different for mechanical materialist, dialectical materialist, Jew, Christian, and entirely different for a Marxist. so i think you discuss it here in very complex, biased , single sided and in holistic manners, try to make it narrow and subjectively clear because it can be controversial objectively. Muhammad Ali Zaidi

Haq is something which a person can derive objectively. If it cannot be derived objectively, then there is nothing in this world which can be considered as truth. I appreciate your point that I failed in presenting my view in this paragraph. Now I've amended it. I hope it will remove the weaknesses in writing. Please observe and comment. Mubashir

Mr. Faraz Inam, Manama, Bahrain

Hope alls well. I was on vacations so couldnt get in touch wioth u. Today i received ur mail regarding a detailed description of ur journies. Seems impressive!!. Faraz Inam

Mr. Jhangeer Hanif, Lahore, Pakistan

I have gone through a couple of paragraphs. It was interesting to read it. The correct translation for safarnama is Itinerary............there has to be "the" before the Quran and the Bible. Jhangeer

Thank you very much for correction and comments. I think the word "itinerary" is used for a travel guide book which is different from a safarnama (collection of observations, feelings and experience of traveller). An itinerary is usually an objective description whereas the safarnama is a subjective thing. Mubashir

I think itinerary does cover these things as well. For instance, according to this entry: Travel literature is travel writing considered to have value as literature. Travel literature typically records the people, events, sights and feelings of an author who is touring a foreign place for the pleasure of travel. An individual work is sometimes called a travelogue or itinerary.

This entry particularly pinpoints FEELINGS of the traveler, which make it subjective as you mentioned. Jhangeer

Mr. Naveed, Karachi, Pakistan

Aap ka bhot bhot shukria yes safanama send karnay ka,

mujhay aisay hitorical place bhot pasand hain. Naveed

Thanks for your comments. Mubashir

روانگی برائے سعودی عرب جدہ مکہ جبل نور اور غار حرا مکہ کے دیگر تاریخی مقامات سفر حج سفر ہجرت مدینہ مدینہ کے تاریخی مقامات بدر احد خندق طائف جازان، ابہا اور فیفا دمام، الخبر اور بحرین کاز وے خیبر، مدائن صالح اور تبوک روانگی برائے اردن پیٹرا جنگ موتہ اور ڈیڈ سی مادبہ، جبل نیبو اور بپتسمہ سائٹ عقبہ مصر کا بحری سفر جزیرہ نما سینا قاہرہ اسکندریہ مصر سے سعودی عرب براستہ اردن